All Or Nothing (Tumblr)

All Or Nothing began as a February 19, 2014 Tumblr joke by discontentramblings imagining a sitcom about an asexual and pansexual roommate pair—title wordplay on their contrasting identities. The thread snowballed into fan art and worldbuilding; on June 16, 2014, teenager Kaye Abernathy (kitkatpaddywak) launched an Indiegogo campaign that blew past a $600 goal to nearly $6,000 before updates stopped and no series appeared.

The failure became Tumblr folklore—cited whenever ambitious fandom crowdfunding looks suspicious. Kaye posted a 2017 apology blaming inexperience and lost funds; discourse never fully died. Know Your Meme published a June 24, 2026 guide as TikTok historians (@mistavelvet, @thesquirrelqueer) revived explainer videos, turning "All Or Nothing" back into a cautionary shorthand for hype outpacing production reality rather than a sincere pitch for the unfinished show.

tumblraon.com can publish an annotated timeline—from discontentramblings' original post through the Indiegogo spike, silence, and 2017 apology—with primary-source screenshots and outbound links so visitors learn Tumblr lore without hosting pirated episodes that never existed.

aoncaution.com fits a crowdfunding literacy site: side-by-side checklists ("scripts? budget? team credits?") illustrated with All Or Nothing and Miss Officer and Mr Truffles case studies, plus printable red-flag cards creators can share when friends hype vague fandom projects.

allornothinglore.com works as a fan-safe pitch bible—character bios, episode one loglines, and fan-art galleries credited to original 2014 contributors—framing the domain as affectionate archival of the idea's creative peak while clearly labeling the Indiegogo outcome as a separate cautionary chapter.